Healing Power: Accepting or Alienating Alternative Medicine?

Public History Student Blog

The Western world has been sceptical and critical about alternative medicine for centuries. In Europe’s early 15th century, witches were burned at the stake, because people believed that they befriended the devil. Nowadays, modern witches obviously do not get burned anymore, but still many people look down on witchcraft and other alternative medicine methods. However, there are also many advocates of alternative medicine, who believe that these methods are far more reliable and safer than regular medicine. In fact, this point of view is actually getting more popular than scepticism.

Integral medicine, an umbrella term for the use of complementary and alternative medicine in combination with regular medicine, is used more often nowadays. This popularity matches the central role of inclusion in today’s society.[1] In connection to this discussion and topic, the Museum Volkenkunde (Museum of Ethnology) in Leiden opened an exhibition, called ‘Healing Power’. In this exhibition, alternative medics have the opportunity to tell their story and explain the medicine methods they practise.

The first sign in the museum tells us about the discussion mentioned above and about how it wants to offer a platform to controversial traditions that are active in the Netherlands. These traditions are based on different cultures, where ritual specialists are called in to reassure the balance between body, soul and spirit. In an interview with the Leidsch Dagblad, conservator Cunera Buijs stated that it is not strange that people are looking for new ways to balance the body, soul and spirit, since we live in such a hectic and stressful society. However, the museum explicitly disclaims accountability, stating: ‘with this exhibition, the museum does not mean to make a statement as to whether these practices work’.

Mixture of Medicine

Although the first sign raises the expectation that the exhibition is focused on Dutch ritual specialists, this could not be further from the truth. The museum may start with various Dutch medics, such as a modern witch, a Mestizo shaman and a kossalite (a special rank in the West African Vodun religion), the exhibition then proceeds to different rooms, focused on other cultures. Not only do we see the traditions that the alternative Dutch medicine methods are based on, but the exhibition also tells us about other ‘non-Western’ traditions and religions among, for example, Northern-Norwegians, the Mongolians and the Canadian Inuit. For me personally, this was quite a considerable transition: from a Brabantian witch to Mongolian religious art.

Moreover, on the topic of art, there was a lot of variety as well. For example: a cross that represents the different stages of life by the Cuban-African artist Santiago Rodiguez Olazábal met the performance The artist is present by Marina Abramoviç, who sat on a chair for days to give people a healing experience. Apart from religious and healing art, there was a third category: critical art. For instance, the first thing you saw when you walked into the exhibition, was Freud White Sacrifice by Sokari Douglas Camp, where Camp shows that she thinks psychoanalysis is a typically Western approach to psychological problems. To me, the mix between religious, healing and critical art was slightly curious, since the three art forms have different goals and origins.

Room with Mongolian religious objects. Courtesy of Museum Volkenkunde.  

Distant topics

The museum presents many different traditions, religions and medicine methods. On the one hand, this offers us a broad range of alternative medicine and its origins. On the other hand, by presenting so many things, the exhibition gets a bit confusing and even worse; it makes the exhibition less understandable and relatable. Of course, it is the Museum of Ethnology, so it should give us a broad image of alternative medicine of different ethnicities. However, it appears as if the exhibition shoots beyond its purpose. If we take a look at the first sign in the museum, it seems the museum wanted to present a platform to alternative medics, who are usually considered controversial, so that they can help ‘normalize’ integral medicine. Of course the museum stated that they did not make any comment about whether these medical methods do or do not work, but it did seem as if they wanted to start a tolerant discussion about alternative medicine, by giving the Dutch medics an opportunity to explain their methods.

However, by showing these Dutch methods in the same exhibition as Mongolian methods, which are based on completely different traditions and even more importantly, on different religions, it seems as if they have alienated the subject of alternative medicine even more. In my opinion, a slightly sceptical visitor will leave this exhibition even more doubtful, after seeing a Dutch modern witch followed by a shamanist in Mongolia. Of course, these traditions are comparable to each other, but for a visitor of the Museum Volkenkunde, I can imagine that the Mongolian shamanism is a too distant subject, with traditions and a religion they cannot relate to.

Point of discussion

With respect to this topic, we can reflect on how museums should contribute to social and medical issues. Is it the role of a museum to engage in a discussion like this or to stay neutral? The National Alliance for Museums, Health and Wellbeing argued in their second report that museums can potentially play a key role in piloting frameworks through which people can be signposted to the cultural and community resources they require.[2] In this case, the Museum Volkenkunde could have given a clear view of what Dutch alternative medicine indicates and how we could use this in combination with regular medicine. Then, it would be up to the visitor to stay sceptical or to engage with the issue. Other religions and traditions could have been shown in a separate exhibition, related to this issue.

In short, I think the Museum Volkenkunde has alienated Dutch alternative medicine by showing them in the same exhibition with other, more culturally distant traditions and religions, which are more difficult to understand and connect with. Since recent scientific studies have shown that today’s society is in need of the inclusion of complementary and alternative medicine, the museum should have split this into separate exhibitions, to create more space for an open discussion about current-day uses of integral medicine.

Lucie van Hulst

[1] R. Hoenders, Appelo, M. and De Jong, J., ‘Integrale geneeskunde: een brug tussen reguliere en alternatieve geneeswijzen passend bij de tijdsgeest’ in GGzet Wetenschappelijk, 18(1), p. 48-63, p. 48.

[2] National Alliance for Museums, Health and Wellbeing, Museums as spaces for wellbeing. A second report from the National Alliance for Museums, Health and Wellbeing (London 2018), p. 54.

79 thoughts to “Healing Power: Accepting or Alienating Alternative Medicine?”

  1. Maybe note that the execution of witches continued well into the 18th century in some European, and is more an early modern practice than a late medieval one. Other than that, interesting article! I really like the propositions you make for improving the function of the exhibition and the way you connect it to the issues we face right now concerning our healthcare system..

  5. Appreciating the persistence you put into your site and detailed
    information you present. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out
    of date rehashed material. Great read! I’ve saved your site and
    I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.
    경마사이트

  7. You can be playing online slots, online blackjack and roulette at your level of stakes in minutes with our easy to use casino finder tool.
    Thousands of players trust these real money online casino sites to provide a secure, enjoyable gaming experience, with valuable casino bonuses relevant to the games they prefer. You can also expect fast payouts on your winnings, with funds reaching your account within days or hours. 바카라사이트인포

  10. This increase came as a surprise to officials who’ve been working to combat problem gambling. In recent years, the number of pokies have been frozen across the state. In addition, pokies have been limited in areas with more vulnerable players, and daily cash withdrawals have been curtailed. 바둑이사이트넷

  12. Great article! That is the kind of information that are meant to be
    shared around the net. Shame on the search engines for now not positioning this
    submit higher! Come on over and discuss with my web site . 홀덤

  13. Online casinos review will help you to know more about the sports betting online: 릴게임사이트 You can know about the casinos where you can play the games safely and securely?
    Obviously, on the off chance that you are at the casino at any rate, you presumably have a superior possibility of succeeding at an aptitude game than a game where you depend totally on shot, so this may be a fun choice for you.

  16. I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you book marked to check out new stuff you post… Look at my homepage.토토

  17. Hi there, I found your website via Google while looking for a related topic, your web site came up, it looks good. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.섯다

  23. Greetings I am so glad I found your weblog, I really found you by error, while I was browsing on Bing for something else,
    Anyhow I am here now and would just like to say thanks a lot for a incredible post and a all round interesting blog. 고스톱사이트

  32. you’rе in point of fact a jyst right webmaster.The website loading vel?city iss amazing.
    It seems that you’rе doing any unique tr?ck. In addition, The contents are masterpiece.
    you have done a wonderful activity in thi? subject! 토토

  33. Hi! I just would like to give you a huge thumbs up for the great info you have got right here on this post. I’ll be coming back to your site for more soon. my web site.
    섯다

  35. Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually understand what
    you’re speaking about! Bookmarked. Please additionally talk over with
    my site =). We can have a hyperlink trade arrangement among us
    안전놀이터

  37. You really make it seem really easy along with your presentation however I find this topic
    to be actually one thing that I believe I would by no means understand.
    It seems too complex and extremely vast for me.
    I am looking ahead for your subsequent publish, I’ll try to get
    the cling of it!
    바카라사이트

  38. Excellent post however I was wanting to know if
    you сould write a litte more on this subjects I’d be very gгateful if you could elaborate a little bit
    further. Many thanks! looking for online casite site? we highly recommended this 100% trusted site and one of the most best site in online casino, if your interested feel free to visit our web site for more information by clicking here 바카라사이트

  40. Online casinos and Toto sites are very convenient alternatives for players who do not have the resources or desire to travel to a real casino. Most online casinos and toto sites add to the freedom of gameplay through the mobile Internet. With the new approach to casino entertainment, players have questions about more mobile sports game features. Casino site 777.info asks the most common questions and gives players insight.
    looking for online casite site? we highly recommended this 100% trusted site and one of the most best site in online casino, if your interested feel free to visit our web site for more information by clicking here 카지노사이트

  42. Thanks for another great article. Where else could anyone get that type of information in such an ideal way of writing? I’ve a presentation next week, and I’m on the look for such info. looking for online casite site? we highly recommended this 100% trusted site and one of the most best site in online casino, if your interested feel free to visit our web site for more information by clicking here 온라인카지노

  43. Excellent post! We are linking to this great content on our website. Keep up the great writing. For those online casino fanatics, we highly recommeded this 100% trusted site of ours! One of the most trusted site among other online casino site. this 100% proven and tested. If you guys looking for fun and if you guys interested, feel free to visit to our website, feel free to ask . kindly click here 스포츠토토
    . Try you luck now, We asure you will Have the fun and and joy your looking for!

  44. Search a Customer Care Number and other Contact Information to connect with Real Human. Get Genuine Customer Service Phone Number. Support Helpline Number. Visit Ask2Human.com

  46. Toto, called Sports Toto, can be legally purchased through lottery rooms in Korea, and the amount of purchase can be bet up to 100,000 won starting from 100 won in total. It is the only Korean online Toto operating under the name of official. 온라인 ㅋㅏㅈㅣ노 Sports Toto is literally limited to sports, so it is a lottery that makes choices based on the results of the competition.

  48. I begqn 디비 writing a blog myself in the last few days and observed loot oof blogs simply rehash old content but add very ittle of value.

  55. I am in fact thankful to the holder of this website who has shared this fantastic post at at this time. looking for online casino site? we highly recommended this 100% trusted site and one of the most best site in online casino, if your interested feel free to visit our web site for more information by clicking here 카지노사이트777

    Online casinos and Toto sites are very convenient alternatives for players who do not have the resources or desire to travel to a real casino. Most online casinos and toto sites add to the freedom of gameplay through the mobile Internet. With the new approach to casino entertainment, players have questions about more mobile sports game features. Casino site 777.info asks the most common questions and gives players insight.

  59. Video poker is based on five-card draw poker, but you don’t actually face any opponents. The aim is simply to make the best five-card poker hand you can. The better your hand, the better your payout can be. This is an easy game to learn, as all that’s involved is choosing which cards to keep and which to discard. 카지노사이트777

  78. It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy.
    I’ve read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you few interesting things or tips.
    Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. 스포츠토토

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.