Say “Digital Humanities” one more goddamn time



The above meme featuring Samuel L. Jackson has circulated amongst students of the University of Amsterdam for the past few years. It is credited to Frank Ridgeway (2012) and sums up feelings of frustration when confronted with yet another lecture teaching the gospel of new, digital research methods and the joys of Big Data. More established historians have also engaged in a debate about digital humanities and although they may have not used quite the same words, article titles such as ‘Veins filled with the diluted sap of rationality: a critical reply’ (Fickers, 2013) speak volumes about the spirited tone of their academic conversation. Concerns are also raised about a possibly narrowing focus on research questions that can be answered using computational methods, rather then adapting software to the questions.

Furthermore, the finite amount of financial funding for humanities-related research and the ever growing portion of it that is allocated towards digital projects leads to uneasiness and a loss of career opportunities for those preferring traditional methods. Considering that a simple google search using the terms ‘digital humanities’+ debate* yields about 1.860.000 hits, this is clearly a controversial topic. However, the very existence of the above digital-born meme and its quick distribution via social media also signals the inevitability of adding digital tools to the historian’s arsenal. This will become an even more pressing issue in the future, since the record of our own time is becoming increasingly more digital then physical.

Debates on topics such as Big Data or the merits of close reading versus distant reading might be relatively new, but the underlying sentiment is not. Traces of it can already be seen in the nineteenth century with its focus on more ‘scientific’ methodologies, plus related concepts such as positivism and technological determinism. Take for instance the historian H.T. Buckle (1821-1862), who devoted a large portion of his life trying to write a never-finished, all-encompassing history of all civilizations in the world, starting with Britain. Buckle did not want to preserve. He wanted to predict, and thought that reading the 22.000 books he accumulated during his lifetime would give him that ability. In his own words: ‘When we perform an action, we perform it in consequence of some motive or motives… those motives are the results of some antecedents, and… therefore, if we were acquainted with the whole of the antecedents (…), we could with unerring certainty predict the whole of their immediate results.’

It is not difficult to imagine the glee Buckle would have felt knowing that at some point in the future, his modern counterparts would be able to search through thousands of documents at the same time, finding correlations in the blink of an eye. Yet such a wealth of information can also be overwhelming. How can you stay focused on your object of research when information is flowing in from all directions, but most of it is presented without context? It is not productive to dismiss technological advances just because they do not mesh with traditional research. New methodologies and concepts are always useful –although the degree varies-, even when applied to topics that have already been studied intensively.

In ‘Big Data for Dead People: Digital Readings and the Conundrums of Positivism’ (2013) Tim Hitchcock describes his experiences with rethinking traditional ways of doing research. Using the vast online archive of London’s Central Criminal Court, Old Bailey, he zooms in on a woman arrested for theft in 1871. He uses her case in order to show how a properly marked up and tagged person of interest can be tracked and traced through time like a human DHL parcel, barcode included. When combined with geographical tools like GIS, available photographs or portraits and social network visualizations, this makes the people of the past more tangible then ever before. Old Bailey is not the only archive that is accessible this way -or working towards it-, and the amount of searchable data is rapidly growing. This is especially the case when the help of volunteers is used for simple tasks such as georeferencing.

At the same time, this raises issues of privacy. Born into a lower social economic class and in her sixties, Sarah Durrant was most likely poor and not in a position to turn down any opportunity to improve her financial situation. Thus, she stole two banknotes in 1871. She received a two-year jail sentence and endured the fear and discomfort that comes with such an event. However, thanks to modern technology, one could argue that she is still publicly shamed for it almost a hundred and fifty years later. She has no unique personality traits; she is remembered as a thief. This lasting consequence of her petty crime is something she could not possibly predict in any way. Is it fair to let this be her only legacy, theoretically accessible for billions of people through google, for many years to come? When a historian tries to show the person behind a written text, does that person not also deserve to be treated as an actual person, dead or not?

Most historians -including myself- might have mixed feelings regarding the privacy issues of the subjects they study. But thinking about this can provide a starting point for discussions and a link to contemporary debates about privacy, Big Data, google and personal representation on social media like Facebook, which captures the Sarah’s of tomorrow in neat little data parcels. Contrary to what Buckle thought, the closer we are to knowing everything there is to know about human beings, the further away their true selves sometimes seem.

Linda van Exter, 14-09-2016


59 thoughts to “Say “Digital Humanities” one more goddamn time”

  1. A very bold start to the semester’s conversations Linda, thanks for sharing the meme!

  2. I agree with you Manon, it is an exciting start! I do not think we fully comprehend yet how our increasing access to tons of data forces us to bring new research strategy. The archival work is changing fast! BTW, it is a great blog!

  3. I together with my buddies were found to be taking note of the nice information and facts found on the blog then unexpectedly I got a horrible feeling I never expressed respect to you for those secrets. Most of the women appeared to be certainly happy to read through them and have now very much been taking advantage of those things. I appreciate you for turning out to be indeed accommodating and then for choosing variety of wonderful areas most people are really wanting to discover. Our own sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to you sooner.

  4. One more thing. I really believe that there are many travel insurance sites of trustworthy companies that allow you enter your holiday details and have you the quotations. You can also purchase the particular international holiday insurance policy on the web by using the credit card. All you have to do is usually to enter the travel specifics and you can view the plans side-by-side. Merely find the package that suits your finances and needs and use your bank credit card to buy it. Travel insurance on the web is a good way to take a look for a reputable company for international travel insurance. Thanks for expressing your ideas.

  5. The information you have posted is very useful. I really enjoy reading and also appreciate your work. Please keep inspiring more readers!

  6. At the start the reason why I write it was to prove that I could, it was to prove that I was good at something and that I had something to share. That is no longer my motive, and it was only ever my motive for that first book. When I started High School I met an English teacher who took me by the hand and let me write as I wanted and let me learn what I wanted to learn. she is the only person to have read my second novel in entirety. The second novel is one that I wrote for many reasons. At first, I was still trying to prove that I had skill and worth, but there was far more at stake this time around because in the time between these books I had become a whole grown person.

  7. It’s actually a cool and helpful piece of information. I am satisfied that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us informed like This. Thank you for sharing.

  8. More information of the media is instilled for the happiness of the people. The roadmap of the media and up essay writing companies is defined for the structures. The opinion is instilled for the fundamental marks for the humans in life.

  9. Good to become visiting your weblog again, it has been months for me. Nicely this article that I’ve been waited for so long. Generate QR Code

  10. The roadmap of the media and up essay writing companies is defined for the structures. The opinion is instilled for the fundamental marks for the humans in life.Swimwear collection

  11. Hello
    I have read so many posts on the topic of the blogger lovers but this piece of writing is in fact a nice article, keep it up.

  12. I really love your blog. Did you develop this website yourself? Please reply back as I’m hoping to create my own site and would love to know where you got this from or just what the theme is named

  13. Are you looking for a home for yourself, your family, staying in Budapest long term due to your work or study? Browse our wide range of properties! Our standard rental contracts are based on a 12 months minimum length and renewable.Immobilien Budapest

  14. Sri Lanka is a country with unique traditions, cultural values and local lifestyles where you will not find anywhere else in the world. With tropical cuisines which hail from the ancient times as well as world-famous crafts such as pottery and drum making, the Sri Lankan essence is sought after by many tourists, which we are ready to provide to you with many enchanting holiday experiences. For visit sigiriya rock sri lanka

  15. Nice post. I learn something new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon everyday. It’s always useful to read articles from other authors and practice a little something from their web sites.reusable food covers

  16. Hello
    I together with my buddies were found to be taking note of the nice information and facts found on the blog then unexpectedly I got a horrible feeling I never expressed respect to you for those secrets.

  17. My name is Slava, I provide the most unique GUIDED TOURS IN ISRAEL focused on your needs with a luxury car for individuals and families, join me for an unforgettable experience! Whether a family trip, business travel or a Bar Mitzvah celebration, I will provide you a lifetime experience, allow me to plan your journey and take care of all the arrangements in Israel, please contact me about different activities in Israel, jeep tours, museums, attractions for kids, Bar Mitzvah ceremony and private tours.

  18. Thank you for sharing this excellent information. Your blog is really cool. It was truly user friendly experience.

  19. Thank you for another excellent post. The place else could anyone get that type of info in such an ideal method of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the search for such chat

  20. I’m thankful for this amazing article now, if you are a student pursuing a course in geography, then chances are that at one point in your academic life you will have to do GIS assignments. As a geologist in the making, your very ultimate goal should always be to surpass all the challenges that academics throw at you.chatrooms

  21. Thanks for the area for letting me publish articles free of lsm99 . And I will help to share for friends or acquaintances Have come to write articles in areas you have provided for online writers. Desktops Computers

  22. Hi, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just wondering if you get a lot of spam feedback? If so how do you protect against it, any plugin or anything you can advise? I get so much lately it’s driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.regtech compliance tools

  23. I am a fan of reading to add insight to information. Thank you for this great blog. this is here, the few months I am visiting and following you. What I really like about you is that your writing style.laundry

  24. Are you looking for a home for yourself, your family, staying in Budapest long term due to your work or study? Browse our wide range of properties! Our standard rental contracts are based on a 12 months minimum length and renewable. Whipper Snipper

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.